Skip to content

What is the difference between an asylum seeker and a refugee?

  • 23 Jun 2022

Turn on the news or pick up your favourite newspaper and you’ll probably hear or read something about refugees and asylum seekers. It’s easy to think of these two terms as the same – but they are very different by definition.

At Baptcare Sanctuary, our work is focused on helping people seeking asylum. We provide supported transitional accommodation to ensure safety, opportunity and a fair go for those seeking asylum.

What is a person seeking asylum?

A person seeking asylum is someone who has fled their own country to seek international protection as a refugee.

Reasons why a person may leave their own country include persecution, a fear of violence and/or human rights violations. Everyone’s story is different.

A person seeking asylum asks for protection while their claim for refugee status is being assessed.

What is a refugee?

A refugee is a person whose request for asylum has been successful. Consequently, their status has changed from person seeking asylum to refugee. To be granted refugee status, a person must pass a rigorous process. Under the Refugee Convention, the assessment of refugee status focusses on whether a person has a well-founded fear of being persecuted on grounds of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular group, or political opinion. Where this does not apply, refugee status won’t be granted. However a person can be granted ‘complementary protection’ if their human rights are likely to be violated – for example through war or torture – in their country of origin.

Once granted refugee status, that person is entitled to protection and assistance.

How is an economic migrant different to an asylum seeker/refugee?

You may have heard the term ‘economic migrant’. This refers to someone who has left their country to seek a better life through improved financial or economic circumstances. (Their reasons may include accessing better job opportunities and/or improved pay).

As economic migrants leave their country for financial and economic reasons (rather than fleeing persecution) they are not entitled to receive international protection as asylum seekers/refugees.

What benefits do people seeking asylum receive from the Australian government?

Not everybody seeking asylum is eligible for government support. Those who are eligible receive basic income support, capped to a maximum of 89% of the Jobseeker payment.

Access to Medicare is broadly dependent on the type of visa held by the person seeking asylum and the conditions of that visa. Visa conditions themselves often change during the application process, creating greater uncertainty. Consequently, many people seeking asylum face problems accessing health services and prescription medicine.

Baptcare and other community service providers support eligible people seeking asylum with access to housing, basic health and social services. We recognise that these are some of the most disadvantaged and vulnerable people in our community.

Are asylum seekers allowed to work?

A person seeking asylum’s right to work and earn income depends on the type of bridging visa they hold, the conditions of that visa, and the progress of their case.

Would you like to learn more about how Baptcare supports people seeking asylum?

Click on the link to read more about our Baptcare Sanctuary program.

If you’d like to get involved and help with donations, employment or volunteering, contact our friendly Sanctuary team at sanctuary@baptcare.org.au

Keep reading

Community news

  • Personal Alert Victoria | Enhancing safety and independence

    Personal Alert Victoria (PAV) offers eligible Victorians a free personal monitoring and emergency response service. This important service is funded by the Victorian Government and helps people continue to live independently at home, safe in the knowledge that help is only a button press away.If you or someone you know is frail, elderly and isolated or who is living with a disability, you may like to consider applying for the PAV program.What does the PAV service involve?The PAV service responds to calls for assistance 24 hours per day.Clients wear a pendant around their neck or wrist which is designed with a button that, when pressed, dials the PAV hotline connecting the caller with trained staff ready to provide assistance. For example, if you fall or suddenly feel unwell, you can press the button and be connected with someone who can speak with you through the pendant.PAV hotline staff will talk with you to determine whether a call should be placed with emergency services, one of your nominated contacts (usually family members, friends or neighbours) or whether you simply require some reassurance about your situation (in the event of a non-urgent issue).How does my pendant connect me to the PAV hotline?A receiver unit sits next to your telephone and is plugged into your telephone line. When it receives an alert from your pendant (after you have pressed the button), the receiver unit automatically dials the PAV hotline.Who is eligible for the PAV service?Eligibility is determined via an assessment conducted in your own home.There are two sets of eligibility criteria to meet – Part A and Part B:Part A:You must meet all three conditions set out below –Daily monitoring – you consent to daily monitoring.Wearable pendant - you are capable of using and willing to wear the PAV pendant at all times.Living situation – you live alone OR are alone for most of the day or evening OR live with a person who would be unable to get to the phone in an emergency (or is unable to use the phone).Part B:You must meet two of these criteria –You have had at least one fall that needed medical attention in the previous six months or be at risk of falls.You suffer from a major medical or chronic condition that puts you at risk of medical emergencies or has some ongoing effect on your health or wellbeing.You are taking six or more different medications on a permanent basis that are prescribed by your doctor / medical specialist.Who conducts my eligibility assessment for PAV?Eligibility assessments for the PAV service are usually conducted by your local council, community health service, aged care assessment service, district nursing service and some publicly funded community rehabilitation services.You can either contact your local service provider directly (for example, by enquiring with your local council’s aged care program) or be referred to an assessment service by your doctor or local community health service.It’s worth noting that there may be a waiting period involved until a PAV unit becomes available for installation at your home.For more detailed information on the PAV program, please refer to the PAV program and service guidelines provided by the Victorian Department of Health.

    • 29 Jul 2024
  • Faces of Baptcare | Meet Durham Smith

    Personal Alert Victoria (PAV) offers eligible Victorians a free personal monitoring and emergency response service. This important service is funded by the Victorian Government and helps people continue to live independently at home, safe in the knowledge that help is only a button press away.If you or someone you know is frail, elderly and isolated or who is living with a disability, you may like to consider applying for the PAV program.What does the PAV service involve?The PAV service responds to calls for assistance 24 hours per day.Clients wear a pendant around their neck or wrist which is designed with a button that, when pressed, dials the PAV hotline connecting the caller with trained staff ready to provide assistance. For example, if you fall or suddenly feel unwell, you can press the button and be connected with someone who can speak with you through the pendant.PAV hotline staff will talk with you to determine whether a call should be placed with emergency services, one of your nominated contacts (usually family members, friends or neighbours) or whether you simply require some reassurance about your situation (in the event of a non-urgent issue).How does my pendant connect me to the PAV hotline?A receiver unit sits next to your telephone and is plugged into your telephone line. When it receives an alert from your pendant (after you have pressed the button), the receiver unit automatically dials the PAV hotline.Who is eligible for the PAV service?Eligibility is determined via an assessment conducted in your own home.There are two sets of eligibility criteria to meet – Part A and Part B:Part A:You must meet all three conditions set out below –Daily monitoring – you consent to daily monitoring.Wearable pendant - you are capable of using and willing to wear the PAV pendant at all times.Living situation – you live alone OR are alone for most of the day or evening OR live with a person who would be unable to get to the phone in an emergency (or is unable to use the phone).Part B:You must meet two of these criteria –You have had at least one fall that needed medical attention in the previous six months or be at risk of falls.You suffer from a major medical or chronic condition that puts you at risk of medical emergencies or has some ongoing effect on your health or wellbeing.You are taking six or more different medications on a permanent basis that are prescribed by your doctor / medical specialist.Who conducts my eligibility assessment for PAV?Eligibility assessments for the PAV service are usually conducted by your local council, community health service, aged care assessment service, district nursing service and some publicly funded community rehabilitation services.You can either contact your local service provider directly (for example, by enquiring with your local council’s aged care program) or be referred to an assessment service by your doctor or local community health service.It’s worth noting that there may be a waiting period involved until a PAV unit becomes available for installation at your home.For more detailed information on the PAV program, please refer to the PAV program and service guidelines provided by the Victorian Department of Health.

    • 27 Jul 2024
  • Enjoying the comforts of home: Lynette and George

    Lynette is 75 and her husband, George, is 70. With a little help from home care, they're able to live healthily and happily together at home.

    • 21 Jun 2024
Read more